And it thickens for a very good reason. There is some debate about the number of plots, subplots, anecdotal plots, and all sorts of other plot related things you can put in a book. It’s generally true that one plot isn’t enough, and in a Malthusian sort of way, it becomes more and more difficult to successfully intertwine additional plots with each new one you add.
What I’ve come to decide upon – at least for my current project – is a few minor plots that wrap around the major plot, and this decision has mostly been influenced by an assortment of articles over at
Fiction Factor.
I should correct myself now; it’s not really a major plot, as much as it is two major plots that are irrevocably bundled together like a strand of DNA, or a binary star pair rotating around a single mutual location. The two main characters (who are conveniently also my protagonist and antagonist) will rotate around this central point and create the main body of story (which is just another way to say the main plot).
That’s all well and good, I have a main plot concept that will continue to propel the story forward and maintain the interest of all my readers until some gripping and powerful climax and denouement. But is that enough?
This is where the question of subplots, secondary plots, et cetera comes into play. Not all authors utilise these narrative elements. I’ve recently decided to read Piers Anthony’s
Bio of a Space Tyrant
quintology, and like many memoir style stories, it has a singular plot and does not dither in elements of other stories. It is true to a single guiding direction with little to no deviation.
Many authors and storytellers, however, do integrate an assortment of secondary narrative elements. Take for example the
Star Wars Trilogy
(yes, I am aware that I relate back to the Holy Trilogy frequently, but that’s because it has such a well known base). There is one central – or main – plot: the destruction of the Evil Empire and the re-creation of the benevolent and democratic Republic. The secondary plots though follow Luke’s education as a Jedi, Han Solo’s evolution from scoundrel to hero, the romance of Han and Leia, and the Vader Plot, or those elements pertaining to the saving of Anakin Skywalker.
Not everyone will have thought about it, but those are the “big” secondary plot elements of the original Star Wars trilogy. They all bolster the central plot (which is, in my opinion, the core purpose of secondary plot), and they all keep us interested in the story.
It’s been suggested (over at
Fiction Factor) that secondary plot is there to distract the reader, particularly that it exists to make sure that the reader never gets bored with the central plot. Imagine Star Wars without the Han/Leia courtship, or without Luke’s frequent Force training. It would be a one-hour long trilogy, consisting of two big balls exploding and a few witty quips. Not worth the money, and certainly not enough to make a thirty year franchise cult.
So, by adding these other elements, Lucas “thickened” his plot considerably, which for every nerd and fanboy is a great thing. But when, for new writers and Secondhand Gods like you and I, is the plot too thick?
Like most questions I pose in my blog, the answer is far too amorphous for a yes or a no. The plot is too thick when it is too thick (tautological yes, but still true). Like making a cake batter, you can accidentally add too much saccharin sugar or one too many eggs and make it far too thick. But that’s why story plotting (an activity I plan on talking about in the next few weeks) is so important, because you can track the events in point form, and remove excess plot as needed.
In my own opinion, there shouldn’t be more than four minor/secondary plots in any single novel (depending on the size of those plots, of course). There is nothing wrong with a romance, a jealousy, an education, but it’s all taken in pinches and dashes of flavour, not pounds. For example, contrary to popular belief, Lucas never did lay the possible Luke/Leia romance on thick, but it has it’s value to infuriate Han, and to upset him as well (this is not entirely a plot in itself, but serves my purpose).
Personally, I intend on using a romantic subplot (with an espionage twist that’ll I’ll talk about another time), and the classic Education subplot, mostly because my story is resting heavily on the shoulders of the
Hero’s Journey. I’ll naturally sprinkle in some jealousy, and I am itching to try my hand at what I am going to call a “future plot,” specifically the use of a character(s) in this story to foreshadow plot in future parts of the story (read as sequels). But most of all, I will make sure not to make it too thick.
I rarely tell you what next week will hold, but I am going to today. Next week I do plan on talking about the nitty gritty of “plotting,” that is, the act of making flow charts, graphs, or even just simple point form lists, of the sequence of events your story will hold. I’ll even talk about some of the cool and interesting methods I’ve discovered. See you then true believers, Excelsior!